Along with (I would imagine) most of the military guys who bother to think about it, I’ve been pissed about the CiC’s backing down from his support of Gen McChrystal. I mean you put the guy in charge, tell him to come up with a plan, he does.. Now it’s time to support him. Or at least do something. Like they used to say in basic, the best thing to do is the right thing, the second best thing to do is the wrong thing, and the worst thing to do is nothing.
Anyways.. I just read this article (via Drudge) In Which a senior US official has resigned his post in Afghanistan, and is now protesting our involvement there. That’s cool – Hoh has a right to speak his mind on such things, both as a citizen and as a stand up guy/former Marine. His resignation letter is worth reading. And the point he makes is something that I don’t doubt – that a lot of the fighting, especially in the remote regions, is with local tribes who have no substantial ties to the Taliban or al Qaeda or anyone else. Historically this is the way it happened, as far back as Alexander the Great. These people are loyal to their own little chunk of mountain and they’ll give guerrilla hell to whatever would-be invader happens to be passing through.
This story does help the case for the administration’s indecision, and will help again if they decide to not give the General his troops. But whatever, I have no reason to think that Hoh’s decision is not legitimate, or that the timing is deliberate. That’s not my problem.
Here’s my problem – As I was reading what this guy said, I realized I was thinking, “Yep, he’s probably right. Meh, I don’t care, I still want to go.”
Wait a minute..
As a Catholic, I believe that war is sometimes acceptible. I also believe that as a Catholic soldier under orders, I am morally justified in following my orders, even if the war is unjust. (Of course, I still must exercise moral judgment for individual orders, eg if ordered to shoot prisoners; but luckily we swear an oath to follow all lawful orders, not every order.)
However, I am morally responsible for the decision whether to place myself under orders in the first place: the decision to enlist, or in my case, re-enlist, which is coming up very soon. If it’s certain that the conflict that I will be sent into is not justified – well then, I probably shouldn’t.
I think I’m ok.. Reading this article is not in itself going to change my opinion on the war. Plus, who knows where I’ll actually get deployed next. Plus, I’m in the Guard, so my responsibility is primarily domestic. Still, I’ve woken up to the fact that I need to think about this more.
I’ve also realized that I need to study my soul and make sure that I have the right motivations. I enlisted for lots of reasons – love of the good old USA, and the example of friends and Americans throughout history; because I wanted the training, and the experience. But you know what.. Largely because, I want to fight. And I don’t really care who. Maybe that will change the first time rounds are flying, but for now that’s the way it is. Annnd.. That’s probably not right.
So.. Dammit. Dammitdammitdammit.
UPDATE: Via Ace, an excellent paper from an SF soldier detailing his proposal for a successful strategy in Afghanistan, based on his experiences there. Read it read it read it. As a bonus, it led to the blog of one of my favorite authors, Steven Pressfield.
What I’m going to do is, start learning about Afghanistan now. If I end up going, great, and if not, it will still be worthwhile – politically, and because it really is a fascinating part of the world. I already read one book about the guy who SHOULD have won the Nobel Peace Prize, Greg Mortenson. Three Cups of Tea is about his work building schools on Pakistan and Afghanistan. Amazing guy.